The Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son Limited (NYSE:NTB) Q4 2022 Results Conference Call February 14, 2023 10:00 AM ET
Company Participants
Noah Fields – Head, IR
Michael Collins – Chairman and CEO
Craig Bridgewater – Group CFO
Michael Schrum – President and Group Chief Risk Officer
Conference Call Participants
Alex Twerdahl – Piper Sandler
Timur Braziler – Wells Fargo Securities
David Feaster – Raymond James
Tim Switzer – KBW
Operator
Good morning. My name is Dave, and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2022 Earnings Call for The Bank of N.T. Butterfield & Son Limited. After today’s presentation, there will be an opportunity to ask questions. [Operator Instructions] Please note, this event is being recorded.
I would now like to turn the call over to Noah Fields, Butterfield’s Head of Investor Relations.
Noah Fields
Thank you. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us. Today, we will be reviewing Butterfield’s fourth quarter and full year 2022 financial results.
On the call, I’m joined by Michael Collins, Butterfield’s Chairman and Chief Executive Officer; Craig Bridgewater, Group Chief Financial Officer; and Michael Schrum, President and Group Chief Risk Officer. Following their prepared remarks, we will open the call up for a question-and-answer session.
Yesterday afternoon, we issued a press release announcing our fourth quarter and full year 2022 results. The press release along with the slide presentation that we will refer to during our remarks on this call, are available on the Investor Relations section of our website at www.butterfieldgroup.com.
Before I turn the call over to Michael Collins, I would like to remind everyone that today’s discussions will refer to certain non-GAAP measures, which we believe are important in evaluating the Company’s performance. For a reconciliation of these measures to U.S. GAAP, please refer to the earnings press release and slide presentation.
Today’s call and associated materials may also contain certain forward-looking statements, which are subject to risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause actual results to differ materially from those contemplated by these statements. Additional information regarding these risks can be found in our SEC filings.
I will now turn the call over to Michael Collins.
Michael Collins
Thank you, Noah, and thanks to everyone joining the call today.
Butterfield’s excellent results in the fourth quarter and full year 2022 benefited from strong positioning in our core banking and private trust markets in Bermuda, the Cayman Islands and the Channel Islands. In addition to these locations, we provide specialized financial and trust services in Singapore, The Bahamas and Switzerland as well as United Kingdom based mortgage lending and high-end Central London. The Bank’s geographic footprint is strategically based across best-in-class offshore banking and trust locations. Our revenue generating operating jurisdictions are efficiently supported in market and in addition by our service centers in Mauritius and Halifax, Canada.
I will now turn to the full year highlights on page 4. Butterfield had an excellent year with net income of $214 million and core net income of $215.7 million. Operating results have increased with rising market rates and resulted in a core return on average tangible common equity at 28.6% for 2022.
In addition to higher net interest income, non-interest earnings were up 4% and expenses held steady, despite some inflationary cost pressures. I was also pleased to see tangible book value per common share recover by 15.7% in the fourth quarter. The net interest margin increased to 2.41% from 2.02% in 2021 with the cost of deposits rising to 34 basis points from 11 basis points in 2021.
The current cycle deposit costs differ somewhat from previous cycles, as a result of our larger banking presence in the Channel Islands, which is more corporate than retail based and therefore more competitive. We continue to pursue an active capital management strategy and have paid out around 40% of earnings in quarterly cash dividends. We are beginning to see our TCE to TA ratio improve towards our targeted range and expect to recommence share repurchases. The Board has approved a new share repurchase authorization for 2023 of up to 3 million common shares which will replace the expiring authorization at the end of February 2023. One of our growth vectors is in-market accretive acquisitions and we are making good progress towards the first closing in the Private Trust asset deal with Credit Suisse that we announced in September last year.
Throughout 2023, we’ll be taking over the administration and servicing of selected Private Trust client structures in Singapore, Guernsey and The Bahamas. We still expect the timing of the onboarding to occur progressively by jurisdiction with the first smaller tranche of Singapore clients coming across at the end of the first quarter, and Guernsey and The Bahamas in the second and third quarters. Our compliance team continues to conduct extensive due diligence at the client level and we are generally pleased with the quality of business so far.
I will now turn the call over to Craig for more detail in the quarter.
Craig Bridgewater
Thank you, Michael, and good morning.
I will begin with slide 6 where be provide the fourth quarter highlights. Butterfield reported net income for the fourth quarter of $63.1 million or $1.26 per diluted common share and core net income of $63.2 million or $1.27 per share.
Our core return on average tangible common equity increased to 34.9% in the quarter from 31.6% in the prior quarter. Our net interest margin improved 20 basis points to 2.79% with the cost of deposits rising 44 basis points to 78 basis points. The Board of Directors again declared a quarterly cash dividend of $0.44 per share. We did not conduct share repurchases during the fourth quarter, although as Michael mentioned, we expect to resume share buybacks as we approach our targeted TCE/TA range of 6% to 6.5% due to deposit stabilization and sustained improvement in OCI marks.
I will now turn to slide 7, which provides a summary of net interest income and net interest margin. In the fourth quarter, we reported net interest income before provision for credit losses of $94.6 million, an increase of 3.7% versus the prior quarter. The increase was due mainly to continued improvement of yields on all interest earning assets, which was somewhat offset by higher deposit costs.
Average cash and short-term investment balances were down $280.1 million during the quarter, driven by expected customer deposit outflows on the funding side. Average investment balances decreased by $152.5 million. We deployed the $108 million of portfolio maturities and short-dated instruments in the fourth quarter of 2022 compared to $90 million in the previous quarter. The average loan balance was down $83.3 million, driven by net maturities in Bermuda and Cayman. Overall, loan yields were up 74 basis points during the fourth quarter, primarily due to the impact of previously announced rate increases on floating rate loans. We had new loan originations of $204 million at an average yield of 5.48% versus $239 million at 4.83% in the third quarter of 2022.
Turning to slide 8. Non-interest income was up 10% quarter-over-quarter, primarily due to higher banking fees, which benefited from increased seasonal credit and debit card transaction activities and higher trust revenue from new business and increased activity based fees. Non-interest income continues to be a stable and capital efficient source of revenues with a fee income ratio of 37.1% up from 35.6% during the third quarter.
Slide 9 provides a summary of core non-interest expenses. Total core non-interest expenses were $84.5 million and 3.3% higher than $81.8 million in the prior quarter and slightly above our targeted run rate. The higher expenses are primarily the results of increased staff related costs, mostly from performance based incentive accruals and severance costs. The core efficiency ratio continued to improve to 55.6% and remains below our true cycle target of 60%.
I will now turn the call over to Michael Schrum to review the balance sheet.
Michael Schrum
Thank you, Craig.
Slide 10 summarizes regulatory and leverage capital levels. Butterfield’s capital levels continue to be significantly above regulatory minimum requirements. Our tangible leverage ratio of 5.6% has improved from 5.0% in the prior quarter due to improved OCI marks in our available-for-sale portfolio.
As we see sustained improvements in the TCE to TA ratio towards our target range of 6% to 6.5%, we plan to recommence share repurchases subject to market conditions. It is important to note that the TCE to TA is not a regulatory ratio for Butterfield and the ex cash ratio also improved to 6.5% and excluding OCI on the securities book, the TCE to TA ratio remained at 8.2%
Turning now to slide 11. Butterfield’s balance sheet remains conservatively managed with a high degree of liquidity. Period-end deposit balances increased by approximately $530 million to $13 billion versus the prior quarter end. The stabilization and increase in deposits came from higher customer volumes as well as the impact of foreign exchange translation of non-U.S. dollar deposits, reversing some of the decline we saw in the third quarter of 2022. Butterfield’s low risk density of 33.9% continues to reflect the regulatory capital efficiency of the balance sheet with a low risk weighted residential mortgage loan portfolio, which now represents 70% of the total loan assets.
Turning to slide 12, here we provide loan and deposit changes by volume and foreign exchange movement, as well as currency by segment. The chart shows the $530 million fourth quarter increase in deposits, which consists of $290 million of underlying deposit inflows, and $240 million due to currency translation changes from a weaker U.S. dollar. New loan originations decreased as expected, but that decline was more than offset by foreign exchange movement.
On slide 13, we show that Butterfield continues to have a strong asset quality with low credit risk in the investment portfolio, which is comprised of 96% AAA rated U.S. government guaranteed agency securities. Credit quality in the loan book also continues to remain robust with non-accrual loans holding at 1.2% of gross loans, and the loan net charge-off ratio, which is up 3 basis points from the prior quarter to 11 basis points.
On slide 14, we present the average cash and securities balance sheet with a summary interest rate sensitivity analysis. The duration of the investment book held steady during the quarter at 5.4 years. We continue to expect asset sensitivity to result in improving NII with higher market rates. Butterfield’s interest rate sensitivity has moderated somewhat due to a higher proportion of fixed rate loans and continued relatively higher sensitivity of U.S. dollar deposits to market rates in the Channel Islands.
I will now turn a call back to Michael Collins.
Michael Collins
Thank you, Michael. I am pleased to note that Butterfield became a member of the UN Global Compact in 2022, which is a public confirmation of our commitment to responsible business practices in the areas of human rights, labor, the environment and anti-corruption. Our ESG program includes a specific focus on climate change and sustainable infrastructure, education and wellbeing, and workforce equity.
Butterfield’s results continue to validate the strengths of our best-in-class operating jurisdictions, sustainable non-interest income, and disciplined expense management that helped drive the efficiency ratio below 60%. As we enter 2023, we believe that Butterfield’s return on common equity will continue to support overall growth objectives and investor returns. Our longstanding strategy remains focused on limiting credit exposure in our conservative investment portfolio, growth through targeted acquisitions, and thoughtful capital management.
Our core markets and market conditions remain constructive for Butterfield’s continuing success, given the proven relatively low risk and high return profile of our business model across recent interest rate and economic cycles. I look forward to working alongside our great teams of people in 2023, and beyond, to help clients achieve their financial goals and enhancing shareholder value.
Thank you. And with that we’d be happy to take your questions. Operator?
Question-and-Answer Session
Operator
[Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from Alex Twerdahl with Piper Sandler. Please go ahead.
Alex Twerdahl
I wanted to ask about the deposit flows you had during the fourth quarter. Obviously, nice to see the reversal after a couple of quarters of outflows. As you look forward into ‘23, do you think that now that deposits are kind of back closer to where they were pre-pandemic that we should see some deposit stability or is there still some at-risk deposit or do you think that maybe there could — actually see some inflows over the next couple of months?
Michael Schrum
Good morning, Alex. It’s Michael Schrum. So maybe I’ll just kick off. Obviously, in the slide deck, you can see the FX movement, which is quite significant in terms of the underlying values that we put on the balance sheet. The underlying deposit flows, as you said, we’ve seen sort of a post-pandemic outflow, net outflow, still a bit elevated, I would say. So, I think we still believe when we look at the retail has held very steady, corporate, particularly in Bermuda and Cayman, is a bit more volatile in terms of business flows. So I still think we will land somewhere in the region of $12.5 billion. So, we’re still a little bit elevated right now. But obviously, we are trying to carefully balance the rate, the cost of deposits with the flows as well. So, I think we’ve done a decent job of that, even though cost deposits are ticking up. But that’s the balance of this part of the cycle. So, I think we are still sort of looking at 12.5%, maybe a little bit higher, maybe a little bit lower, but thereabout.
Alex Twerdahl
Okay. And then in the same — I guess, correlated to that, as you think about cash flows from the investment portfolio. I think last year it was — most it is expecting the cash flows to kind of turn into cash. Have you changed the strategy? Are you are thinking about reinvesting some more, just given a little bit more stability expectations?
Michael Schrum
Yes. So, yes is the short answer. I mean, it’s geography to some extent, so we have a latter T-bill portfolio in our cash and short-term securities. Obviously, that’s helpful in terms of not having any more OCI coming into the FX book impacting TCE. So again, we’re just kind of sitting there until we kind of start the march back, and we were pleased to see a recovery obviously of the TCE this quarter, helped by some of the OCI marks coming back a little bit. So, as I — as well, we are pretty conservative. So, we are going to kind of — short-term rates are still pretty productive. But over time, obviously, we want the fixed rate assets in investment portfolio. So, maybe a couple of quarters more and see how rates develop and then we should be re-laddering out and going back to BAU.
Alex Twerdahl
Okay. That’s great. And then you talked a little bit about the deposit pressures starting to pick up a little bit, specifically in the Channel Islands. So, I was wondering if you could help us, just get a little bit better sense for how we are thinking about — or how you’re thinking about overall deposit betas in the various jurisdictions?
Michael Schrum
Yes. So I’ll kick off and then Craig can also chime in. Obviously, the exit run rates are a bit higher. If you look at the March, particularly on the term deposit side, it has really largely been due to the Channel Islands, where again we don’t have a significant enough market share to have an impact on the pricing in those markets. And we’re still trying to grow market share, obviously there. And it is just a more competitive environment. And our banks there are primarily mid-market commercial banks. And so again, there’s more price sensitivity in those markets.
In terms of how we think about the betas in Bermuda and Cayman, that hasn’t really changed very much in terms of the deposit beta. So, I think for demand, we model something like a 30% beta, and I think, we’ve outperformed that across the cycles. And in term deposits, we sort of model a 70%. Again, we want to have the opportunity to give customers a reasonable rate if they go on to term with us. And obviously there’s the money fund as well.
So, those on a back testing basis are pretty conservative assumptions for those two markets, really. And then the Channel Islands, we’re obviously a little bit newer to the market, and so we’re modeling it at a little bit more aggressive deposit betas. These are through cycle. I think, we’re sort of peaking in terms of deposit betas right now, in Channel Islands, but they’ve been pretty close to a 100% actually.
Craig Bridgewater
I think, part of it is Alex in Channel Islands, it’s very much a — we are very much of a corporate bank today. We’ve launched our sort of mass affluent retail initiative recently. We have over 200 million sterling in mortgages now, and sort of over about a 100 million in deposits. So over time, I think the Channel Islands will become — funding will become somewhat less expensive as we grow the retail book. But today it’s very much a corporate book, but I think that will change over time. It’ll start to look a little bit more like Bermuda and Cayman, but it’ll take some time to get there.
Operator
Our next question comes from Timur Braziler with Wells Fargo Securities. Please go ahead.
Timur Braziler
On the buyback, I just want to make sure, I’m hearing you correctly. You’re re-upping it. You’re optimistic about the trajectory of TCE. I guess are you still waiting to get to that 6% level before you reengage, or are you starting to reengage already? And then, as a follow-up, if there’s still — I think it’s a 2 million share authorization remaining through the end of February. Could we actually see you guys tapping into that in addition to the 3 million shares, or is the 3 million shares kind of a little bit higher than the prior year to serve as a catch-up for kind of shares not purchased during ‘22?
Craig Bridgewater
Thanks, Timur. I guess probably a few points just to tee it up is, kind always said that, as we structure a pathway back into our range of 66.5%, we’ll give consideration to whether we go back into the market, and commence our share repurchases. And as you can see that we are kind of marching towards that. So, at the end of December, I think, we’re like a 5.6, and we’re kind of seeing positive conditions around that.
And then secondly, we always like to have a program that’s authorized. So to your point, we do have the existing one that expires at the end of February. So, that’s available to us. And then, what we did announce yesterday is a renewal — or replacement program of 3 million shares to take us through to next February. And we’ll continue to look at that. And we’re really happy that we just finished our Board meetings yesterday, the Board approve that and we’re very supportive of going back into the market for share repurchases, obviously subject to market conditions. So, we are seeing some nice activity on the shares this morning, which is good to see. But yes, we are kind of having internal discussions and looking at recommencing share buybacks. And we do have the current program available to us as well as come March for us we have the new program.
Michael Schrum
Yes. And I think Tim — sorry, it’s Michael Schrum, can add to that. I think the pace will probably be slower in the first half of the year is what we would expect. We just want to see conditions kind of stabilize, both deposit levels and OCI. But I think that’s how we think about it internally.
Timur Braziler
Got it. I appreciate that. And then you had mentioned that you extended a large line of credit to the Cayman government. Can you quantify the size of that? And as you are looking at the loan book through ‘23, is there any kind of visibility to other chunky activities taking place, or does that come up a little bit more, I don’t want to say unexpected, but is that situation a little bit more fluid and seeing that pipeline there?
Craig Bridgewater
Yes. So, the size of the one that was extended during 2022 was kind of mid-teens to the Cayman Islands government. And obviously, that’s kind of been also amortizing and paying down over the last couple of months as well. So, it’s kind of somewhere around 12 to 13 at this point. That is — obviously, we continue to kind of focus on those relationships, those significant relationships. Nothing significant in the pipeline at the moment, but as those opportunities come up, we are always kind of willing to put our hats in the ring. As long as the terms and conditions are appropriate, the pricing is appropriate, we’ll extend those types facilities.
Timur Braziler
Great. And then just last for me, looking at your expectation on the deposit side, the fact that we still have some lagging rates to be put into the Bermuda mortgages. Just looking at net interest margin and kind of putting all that together, is the expectation here kind of steady as she goes, as these two dynamics work out at least in the first quarter or do you see slowing or maybe even reversal as you start getting more pressure on the funding base and asset yields slow down a little bit?
Michael Collins
Yes. Great question. Obviously, the first thing is, it depends on where market rates are. I would say, our exit run rates for the fourth quarter were — continued to have that NIM expansion at a slower pace than what we’ve seen in Q3 and Q4. So obviously, you saw the big uptick in Q3, and then a slightly more moderate uptick in NIM in Q4. And it’s worth just mentioning, we still have two announced base rate increases in the Bermuda residential book, which are coming through in Q1.
So, when you put it all together, the cash and short-term securities will continue to trend up, loans will trend up a little bit, but there is about 40% fixed in that. And then obviously, securities when we start to re-ladder should reinvest at much higher rate as we start to see TCE coming back. So, we kind of see a path of a longer expansion as long as the rates market remains constructive for us, which is somewhere where we are sitting at the moment, a little bit higher, a little bit lower, but there’s still additional expansion to come.
Timur Braziler
Got it. And what’s the magnitude of the two announced base increases on the Bermuda book?
Michael Schrum
Both 25 basis points.
Timur Braziler
25 each, so 50?
Michael Schrum
Yes.
Timur Braziler
Great. Thank you.
Michael Schrum
Sorry, Tim. I have to correct myself. So, sorry, that Cayman facility is in the region of 150. I was actually thinking, I was thinking it’ll be tenure when I said kind of mid-teens, so that’s actually tenure of it. But it’s in the region of 150.
Timur Braziler
Okay. That’s 150 million commitment. And that’s fully drawn down, or is that only a part of that is…
Michael Schrum
Yes.
Timur Braziler
Okay, great. Thanks for the color. I appreciate it.
Operator
Our next question comes from David Feaster with Raymond James.
David Feaster
I would just want to maybe get a quick economic update from you all. We’ve got the restrictions now lifted in the island economies, great to see the uptick in the banking fees. Obviously, there’s some seasonal benefits there, but just curious, the pulse of your local economies from your perspective. How inflation and higher rates are impacting the local businesses there? And then just any expectations for that banking fee line item as well?
Michael Collins
Yes. Thanks for the questions. I mean, I think all the economies in our jurisdictions are actually doing quite well. It is seasonal in a sense. So obviously, the fourth quarter came in sort of late November, Thanksgiving through December is actually really busy. That’s their high season. But on the other hand, Bermuda is the low season from a tourism perspective. So, it balances out, Bermuda’s holding its own. Reinsurance industry is doing well. We’ve sort of — have a whole new type of reinsurance company over the last 5 to 10 years, life reinsurers. So, as property catastrophe is actually waned a bit, Bermuda’s reinvented itself again. So, reinsurance and international business is doing well.
We do have a bit of a problem in terms of flight capacity, which Cayman doesn’t have. Cayman has tons of flights. Bermuda today has fewer flights, and we’re working with the airlines to try to get more capacity. But economy’s doing reasonably well. Cayman is doing very well, so expanding population growth, lots of new people sort of setting up there, and the Channel Islands is doing quite well as well. So all the economies are doing well, everything’s open. Bermuda, I think, will have a good summer season. So, so far so good. In terms of cost-of-living Bermuda, Cayman have always been very expensive.
So, I think inflation isn’t any surprise here. We’ve talked in the past, we haven’t seen any credit stress at this point, but we’re keeping an eye on it as rates go up. But so far there’s enough indigenous wealth and saved wealth in Bermuda in particular that we haven’t seen any real credit stress. So, we’ll keep an eye on it, but we’re quite positive about the way all four economies are looking on the banking side.
David Feaster
Okay. That’s helpful. And maybe to the point on credit, it was great to see the decrease in non-accruals. Obviously, we’re not seeing anything significant. Could you maybe just talk about what drove that decline? And then just curious on your mortgage clients, and how they’re holding up with higher rates on those floating rate mortgages and your approach to working with those borrowers that may be struggling more, and whether there’s just anything on the credit front that you’re watching or maybe concerned about at this point. Sounds like there might not be much, but just wanted to but just wanted to touch on that.
Craig Bridgewater
Hi, David. It’s Craig. I guess to answer the first question in regards to the decreases in non-accrual. So, we actually had a non-accrual loan that was paid down. So, that’s kind of come off the books. So, that was a very positive development in regards to our credit loan book, during the quarter. It was a facility in the UK and a very kind of unusual circumstance, if you will, that caused it to come up. And something that we necessarily wouldn’t see — expect to reoccur, but that will settle and that was paid down. So, that’s good news.
And then just going forward, in Bermuda in particular, the credit risk management team has been working really, really hard to get a good understanding of clients’ experiences, the potential impacts on loan affordability or payment affordability of loans, as the interest rates have increased over 2022. So, we are very focused on that. And so far, we haven’t seen anything come through, no indications of any decreases in credit quality. So, no missed payments, kind of not seen anything unusual when it comes to missed payments or days past due. Usually kind of around Christmas time people do ignore the mortgage payments at least for the month as they are going to Christmas and make sure that they have — want to make sure they have a good Christmas and kind of bringing happiness to the family. But that’s kind of seasonal and that’s — we don’t see that as being unusual.
Michael Collins
And it’s a different market in the sense that we — as you know, we don’t do credit scoring. We have so few mortgages and the average size of the mortgage is much higher than you would see in the U.S. So, we actually — in both Cayman and Bermuda, we actually know each property. So when someone is getting into trouble and struggling a bit, where we’ve got our arms around it, we actually know how to restructure it. We know what it will sell for. So, it is really underwriting mortgage-by-mortgage. So, it’s a very different market. So, it’s such small — there is such small places that I think we get intelligence very early when certain borrowers are struggling, but we are just not seeing at this point, irrespective of Christmas, which is very important in the islands.
David Feaster
That’s right. That’s helpful. Thank you. And then, maybe just touching on the acquisition. Just curious, it sounds like we might be getting some revenues here in the first quarter. Just kind of curious how due diligence has been going? I know it’s a time consuming process. Whether you are seeing more clients that meet your thresholds than you’d initially expected? And then just, if you could provide us any financial impacts from the deal or is it still just too early to tell?
Michael Schrum
Hi, David. It’s Michael Schrum. So yes, teams are working very diligently on pushing both the consents through the systems of any client consent in order to actually do the due diligence, and that’s going pretty well, a little bit slower, a lot of questions from clients around, hey, what’s this all, and so needing to explain what’s happening. But it’s a good conversation. Once we stop the DD process, we have sort of a checklist for fiduciary and for obviously any flags that we see on the file. We also check for missing documents. And so far what we have seen, we started really with Singapore and Bahamas. It has been very high quality of client files. It’s also a slightly younger book than the Guernsey book. And we’re very pleased that we are going to be closing the first tranche of clients at the end of the first quarter here.
There’s still a few moving pieces I can — it’s not going to be material, but it is — it’s obviously helpful both for the Singapore entity, and it’s helpful for a fee income, as a whole. But it’s not a large acquisition and there’s still some moving parts around which clients are actually coming across. And so I think — and there’s some movement in which staff are coming to service the clients. So, we’ll definitely come back, at the end of the quarter when we have certainty around the closing population, and talk a bit about what the pipeline is as well.
I think, overall, the deal’s still within the stated parameters. The clients are — some of them are fantastic trust clients, and there’s a lot of additional opportunity for us to look at going forward. But the initial push has really been to just kind of get it through the system. I would say there’s very few differences in the risk appetite. There are some, and that’s been put to sort of an arbitration committee to kind of discuss, and figure out whether we reject or whether there’s some way that we could take them on within a conditional way.
So that discussion has been productive. So, I think, overall, it’s going well. There are some great clients, and Michael and I have been on early calls in Singapore talking to some of the families, talking through the process, and what they can expect to happen. So, very pleased with the quality, very pleased with the way that Credit Suisse has cooperated as well during this process. They’ve obviously got a lot going on, but I think they — very committed to getting this done with us, and so that’s been very helpful as well.
Yes. So financials, like, it’s a little earlier still, there’s still some moving pieces, but we’re definitely keen to come and talk about the next quarter.
Michael Collins
Yes. I think, we’re really happy about the quality of the client. So, I think what you — what we’re seeing is generational wealth in Asia. So the source of funds is pretty straightforward, because you can see industrial companies going down through generations. And so it’s a process. It takes a long time to move trust, it’s laborious. You’ve got to get client consent. Credit Suisse is being extremely supportive and helpful. It’ll take some time. But I think we’re very happy with the quality of clients.
Operator
[Operator Instructions] Our next question comes from Tim Switzer with KBW. Please go ahead.
Tim Switzer
I had a quick follow-up on I guess your M&A pursuits and interest, just — I know it’s — you guys have been spending a lot of time doing this due diligence. Do you still have appetite to maybe acquire another trust business this year if you find the right opportunity, or is that kind of on the back burner for now? And then similar question if — I know with bank M&A, you don’t have too many options, but is that still of interest to you as well?
Michael Schrum
Yes. Thanks for the question, Tim. It’s Michael Schrum. So, the answer is we’re still interested and these things have a — tend to have a long gestation period and they tend to be a few curve balls, as you go through the negotiations. So, there’s still active dialogue. The CS deal took the better part of a year to kind of get from initial conversations to some of that work for everybody. And then, it’s another year to kind of get that team set up and integrate. So, in terms of just having conversations and making that pipeline work, and there are still some great opportunities for us out there both in Singapore, but also in our other jurisdictions, where I think coming out of COVID, some of the bigger franchise banks are looking at that business as a complex, low growing business in small places. And so, we would definitely be in the natural bias eventually.
It’s just — the gestation period is a bit longer and sometimes it doesn’t work for both parties at the same time. So definitely still an appetite. Parameters are still the same. So, we are paying up to 8 times EBITDA pre-synergies in market, maximum outlay of $50 million. Now if something big did come along, we would obviously take a look at it. So smaller acquisitions, we can get our arms around it, we can integrate it, and it’s accretive with the high ROEs that we are posting at the moment. Obviously, the hurdle rates for the IRRs for the deals are still at 15%, but they got to be at a certain 15% in order to be accretive. And so, these things — these are not financial acquisitions, that are kind of strategic moves for the sellers and for us. So yes, still definitely a handful of good opportunities, nothing to talk about yet. And maybe they end up going away and coming back again, who knows. But there is still appetite in the bank and the trust company.
Tim Switzer
Okay, great. And for the margin outlook, you guys talked about you expect a little bit of expansion still. It seems like in Q1, but what’s the trajectory over the rest of 2023, assuming we get maybe another 50 basis points of hikes or something from the Fed. If the Fed pauses, is there a moderation in the margin in the back half of the year, as deposit costs continue to rise, but loan yields settle out or do you think you’d be able to maintain the NIM?
Michael Collins
Yes. So we would see it as — the drivers of the NIM expansion really are, as you correctly said, you see a moderation in the loan, both in terms of new originations are starting to moderate at higher rates. And there is obviously a fixed component that’s flawed, if you will. But retail loans, on the exit run rate is still up a fair bit for us. What’s going to kick in, in a more meaningful way for us is the re-laddering of the cash as we see deposit stabilization. The exit run rate on the cash is pretty low, but it’s definitely getting there in terms of just the T-bills rolling over. And that will discontinue really as we roll into longer-dated fixed rate maturities. And then deposit costs, we would expect them to moderate in terms of cost for now, but it just depends on what the market then does. We have to remain competitive certainly in fix income bucket. Obviously, that’s where we have the — this is the first rate cycle we have done since the ABN acquisition in sterling in the Channel Islands. And so, this is a bit of a learning experience. But I think our model assumptions are still very conservative. And as you can see on the asset sensitivity with another 100 basis point, even 200 basis points, we are not expecting — we are expecting moderation in the asset sensitivity but not flat lining, if that makes sense.
Tim Switzer
Yes. That all makes sense. Thank you. That’s all for me.
Operator
This concludes our question-and-answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to Butterfield for any closing remarks.
Noah Fields
Thank you, Dave. And thanks to everyone for dialing in today. We look forward to speaking with you next quarter. Have a great day.
Operator
The conference has now concluded. Thank you for attending today’s presentation. You may now disconnect.
Be the first to comment