There’s still more evidence that active investing doesn’t work as advertised (emphasis added):
In 11 out of the 18 categories of domestic equity funds, the majority of funds continued to underperform their benchmarks. For example, 67% of domestic equity funds lagged the S&P Composite 1500® during the one-year period ending June 30, 2020. Additionally, the majority of large-cap (63%) and multi-cap (65%) funds lagged their benchmarks. In contrast, mid-cap and small-cap active funds performed relatively better. Approximately 56% of mid-cap and 53% of small-cap active managers outperformed their benchmarks for the one-year period.
While one could argue that smaller-cap active management is an option, the same report also contains this table that shows the performance of various fund types over various time frames:
But passive investing is also (potentially) facing a period of low returns. The 60/40 portfolio (60% stocks/40% bonds) has been an investing staple for decades (which is why I report on various returns based on different allocations weekly). But now managers are concerned this allocation is facing choppy waters based on long-term projections (as in years) of low equity market return. I’m dubious of any long-term market value prognostication; there is simply no way of knowing what’s going to happen by year-end, let alone in five years. This is the primary fault with active portfolio management. More importantly, the primary reason for using some level of stock/bond allocation is that these assets are somewhat negatively correlated as shown in this chart from the Portfolio Visualizer website: The SPY and TLT continue to be negatively correlated over time which is a primary reason the two assets are combined in portfolios.
According to the latest PMI release from Markit Economics, the US economy is expanding:
- U.S. Composite Output Index at 54.4 (54.6 in August) 2-month low.
- U.S. Services Business Activity Index at 54.6 (55.0 in August). 2-month low.
- U.S. Manufacturing PMI at 53.5 (53.1in August) 20-month high.
- U.S. Manufacturing Output Index at 53.3 (52.7inAugust) 10-month high.
Here’s the commentary from the report:
“US businesses reported a solid end to the third quarter, with demand growing at a steepeningrate to fuel a further recovery of output and employment.“The survey data therefore add to signs that the economy will have enjoyed a solid rebound in the third quarter after the second quarter slump
Overall, this is further confirmation that the economy has rebounded from the lockdown-caused lows.
Let’s take a look at today’s performance tables:All the equity indexes were lower; the only issue was the amount of the decline. The QQQ led the way lower, which is to be expected as it’s been the top-performing index for some time. After that, smaller-caps had the largest losses. The long end of the Treasury market was up fractionally.
Now the sector performance is taking on a more standard sell-off posture. Health care, staples, and utilities — the three defensive sectors — are the “best-performing.” The energy market — which is in terrible fundamental shape — had the largest losses.
Let’s start by looking at today’s QQQ chart:This is a standard-issue down day, with prices moving from the Northwest to the Southeast and ending just slightly above the daily low. The 200-minute EMA acted as technical resistance starting in the late AM.
Yesterday, I noted that this looks like a correction and not the start of a bear market. The daily QQQ chart explains why:Prices are forming a pennant pattern, which occurs in an uptrend and is usually a continuation — not a reversal — pattern. Volume is decreasing, which is also standard for this situation.
Let’s now look at a few charts that are key for whether or not this stays a correction or if this leads to a wave of stronger selling:
This leads to two questions:
- Will the smaller-caps continue lower and will they pull larger-caps down? Larger and small-cap stocks have been less correlated during the last few months, so one could argue that they won’t.
- Will the larger-caps continue to comply with the basic technical rules of a pennant patter or will their selling accelerate?
At this point, we’ll need another trading day to answer.
Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.