3M Is Struggling, So Buy These 7+% Yielding Dividend Aristocrats Instead (NYSE:MMM)

Hundred US Dollar are Falling On White Background — Baris-Ozer

This article was originally published on Dividend Kings on Tuesday, December 6th.

A comfortable or even rich retirement is the dream of all investors. If you want to build life-changing wealth and retire in safety and splendor, there is no better strategy than blue-chip stocks.

Despite many ups and down, the US stock market has delivered 7% annual inflation-adjusted returns for 220 years.

An incredible 2.9 million X return

That same 7% real return is what investors have enjoyed in the past:

100 years
70 years
20 years

How can stocks deliver 7% real returns when the economy constantly changes? Because stocks are ownership in real companies, run by skilled managers and executives who adapt as challenges arise.

However, that doesn’t mean you can buy just any blue-chip, walk away for decades, and hope to get rich.

44% of all stocks fail catastrophically, meaning they fall 70+% and never recover. This can happen even to the bluest of blue-chips.

Back in 2000, General Electric (GE) was considered by many to be the greatest stock in the world.

A-credit rating
dividend aristocrat
the world’s most valuable company
Jack Welch, its CEO, was named Fortune “CEO of the Century.”

GE is still down 68% off its 2000 highs, including dividends. Dividends which, on an annual basis, it’s cut five times in the last 20 years.

And GE is just the most extreme example of a failed aristocrat.

General Electric (68% below its 2000 high)
AT&T (T) (zero inflation-adjusted returns for 20 years)
CenturyLink (now Lumen Tech) down 77% off its highs in 2015 after two dividend cuts and then suspending its dividend entirely
Winn-Dixie (bankrupt)
K-Mart (bankrupt) was acquired by Sears (which also went bankrupt)

The point is that just because a company is a dividend aristocrat doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a “buy and hold forever” stock.

“Our favorite holding period is forever.” – Warren Buffett

This famous quote from the greatest investor of all time doesn’t mean buy and blindly hold forever. It means to buy and hold forever or until the fundamentals break, whichever comes first.

“When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?” – John Maynard Keynes

There are no sacred cows at iREIT or Dividend Kings. Wherever the fundamentals lead, we always follow. That’s the essence of disciplined financial science, the math behind retiring rich and staying rich in retirement.

This brings me to the topic of 3M (NYSE:MMM), which has been struggling with a turnaround for several years. Recently 3M’s fundamentals have taken a turn for the worse, so I wanted to update Dividend Kings members about the good and bad about this 4.7% yielding dividend king.

I also want to offer Altria (MO) and Enbridge (ENB), and two higher-yielding and faster-growing aristocrat alternatives. Aristocrats who are currently firing on all cylinders and offer a more attractive reward/risk ratio than 3M.

The Good News About 3M

3M’s bear market began in 2018 and has now lasted four years. The stock has fallen by as much as 50% off its highs.

That alone doesn’t indicate the thesis is broken. After all, valuation explains much of 3M’s bear market.

In early 2018, 3M was trading at nearly 30X earnings, a 50% historical premium. For context, the S&P 500’s peak valuation during the tech bubble was 25X, also a 50% historical premium.

Whenever a blue-chip becomes 50% historically overvalued, it’s a warning to either trim some or at least avoid it.

BTI’s current bear market began when it was 50% overvalued
MO’s current bear market began when it was 50% overvalued
Midstream began its multi-year bear market when it became 50% overvalued

Blue-chip bear markets can last as long as seven years, and bubbles can last almost as long. Why? Because it takes 7 years for fundamentals to overtake sentiment and momentum to drive the majority of returns.

Time Frame (Years)	Total Returns Explained By Fundamentals/Valuations
1 Day	0.02%
1 month	0.33%
3 month	1.0%
6 months	2.0%
1	4%
2	12%
3	20%
4	28%
5	36%
6	47%
7	58%
8	68%
9	79%
10+	90%
20+	91%
30+	97%

(Source: DK S&P 500 Valuation Tool, JPMorgan, RIA, Princeton, Fidelity, BAC)

3M’s earnings never fell 50%. In fact, they haven’t fallen at all.

2018 EPS: $9.98
2022 EPS: $10.20
2018 dividend: $5.44
2022 dividend: $5.96

3M’s bear market began due to high valuations when its growth stalled, partially due to the trade war. Since then, it’s faced the Pandemic, the 2023 recession, and of course, a troubled turnaround.

Its PFAS and ear plug liabilities are the single biggest source of fear, uncertainty, and doubt.

So is 3M the next GE or AT&T, or CenturyLink?

Nothing in wide-moat 3M’s latest results materially alters our long-term view of the firm…We were, however, caught off guard by the reduced sales guidance. Foreign exchange is a headwind, but even the organic guidance fell 75 basis points at the midpoint…

Litigation fears hover over 3M stock, which we think are responsible for the shares’ persistent price/value gap. While we think this discount implies far too high a liability related to its PFAS and Combat Arms litigation, 3M’s bankruptcy court loss removes a vital catalyst in the stock.”- Morningstar

Most likely not, as 3M’s recent weakness is mostly due to the global economic slowdown.

However, 3M’s fundamentals have weakened considerably, making me a lot less excited about the company.

3M’s Thesis Isn’t Broken

3M’s yield is at its highest in 40 years, other than the October 13th market low.

The investment thesis on 3M is the same as it is for all dividend blue-chips.

Yield + long-term growth = total returns, with valuations canceling out over 30+ years.

If the yield is attractive enough AND SAFE, then it doesn’t take much growth for a blue-chip to be a potentially attractive buy.

3M’s nearly 5% yield is enough to get a lot of investors’ attention, and the good news is that it’s still very safe. Why? Let’s start with the payout ratio.

2022 consensus: 63%
2023 consensus: 59%
2024 consensus: 56%

For context, rating agencies consider 60% or lower payout ratios safe for industrials.

How about 3M’s free cash flow stability?

3M’s free cash flow has remained stable, if rather stagnant, and isn’t expected to reach new highs until 2025.

But the dividend, while slow growing, is expected to remain well covered by cash flow.

Ok, so free cash flow isn’t too much of a concern regarding dividend safety, but what about the balance sheet? If a company is drowning in debt, then even a well-covered dividend might not be safe.

3M’s debt/EBITDA ratio is 2.4X and is expected to fall to 1.7X in 2023.

Rating agencies consider 3X or less safe for industrials, so 3M’s debt isn’t a concern, and it currently has $7.8 billion in liquidity.

It’s still an A+ rated company, though with a 33% chance of being downgraded to A, according to S&P.

due to legal liability concerns
0.6% 30-year bankruptcy risk that could increase to 0.66%

The bond market, via credit default swaps, provides real-time fundamental risk assessment and isn’t overly concerned about 3M either.

the stock price is a lot more volatile than its fundamental default risk
which remains very low on an absolute basis

Obviously, the biggest risk to 3M’s dividend king status is the ear plug liabilities.

For 3M’s Combat Arms earplugs litigation, we earmark a liability of just over $3 billion based on inflation-adjusted comparable cases and the number of cases pending.” – Morningstar

The good news there is that the final cost of 3M is likely to be a lot lower than the worst-case scenarios you might see in news articles.

Almost all class-action lawsuits of headline-grabbing size are overturned on appeal or reduced by 50% or more.

Two Army Veterans Awarded $110 Million in 3M Earplug Lawsuit

I’m an Army vet myself, so I’m not anti-military in any way. But I think we can all agree that $55 million for hearing loss is a bit excessive. This was a jury award that awarded punitive damages to “stick it to big business.”

It’s very easy to be generous with other people’s money. How do I know that this is a ridiculous award that will almost certainly be overturned or reduced by nearly 100%?

If you extrapolate this latest award across all 300,000 pending cases, you get $13.5 TRILLION.

This is for earplugs that 3M made based on military specifications. In other words, they weren’t defective; they were designed based on what the military wanted. It turns out the military underestimated how much noise would cause permanent damage, and now 3M is being villainized as “evil.”

thus such outlandish punitive jury awards

Will 3M spend many years battling in the courts? Most likely.

Is this going to act as an overhand for the stock? Almost certainly.

So does that mean that 3M might be a screaming bargain for many years, allowing patient high-yield investors to buy and reinvest dividends and build life-changing positions?

To answer that, let’s consider 3M’s long-term risk management and growth prospects.

3M’s Risk Management Is World-Class

What are the risks 3M faces?

3M is exposed to several risks, including slowing organic growth and supply chain-related disruptions, end-market weakness, a slowdown in industrial production, execution risk related to its acquisitions of MModal and Acelity in 2019, and market rejection of new product introductions.” – Morningstar

Some are short-term cyclical, like a slowing economy. Others are temporary, like supply chain disruptions. Intrinsic risks lie in its products losing market share to rivals like Honeywell (HON).

Fortunately, 3M’s R&D efficiency is the stuff of legend, ranked alongside Apple (AAPL) and Alphabet (GOOG) (GOOGL) in converting R&D spending into profits.

Our survey of prior environmental and product liability cases leads us to assume that a low- to mid-single-digit billion-dollar liability (present value) is far more likely.” – Morningstar

This leaves around $7 billion in likely legal liabilities as its biggest risk. Now that sounds pretty scary but remember two things:

3M has $7.8 billion in liquidity right now
it’s generating a stable $6 billion per year in free cash flow
legal verdicts like these are generally paid out over 15 to 30 years

In other words, unless 3M ends up with a much higher liability than most analysts, rating agencies, and bond investors expect, it’s not likely to go bankrupt or even cut its dividend due to these legal liabilities.

And let’s not forget that 3M has a history of incredibly successful long-term risk management. How do we know?

DK uses S&P Global’s global long-term risk-management ratings for our risk rating.

S&P has spent over 20 years perfecting their risk model
which is based on over 30 major risk categories, over 130 subcategories, and 1,000 individual metrics
50% of metrics are industry specific
this risk rating has been included in every credit rating for decades

The DK risk rating is based on the global percentile of how a company’s risk management compares to 8,000 S&P-rated companies covering 90% of the world’s market cap.

MMM scores 89th Percentile On Global Long-Term Risk Management

S&P’s risk management scores factor in things like:

supply chain management
crisis management
cyber-security
privacy protection
efficiency
R&D efficiency
innovation management
labor relations
talent retention
worker training/skills improvement
occupational health & safety
customer relationship management
business ethics
climate strategy adaptation
sustainable agricultural practices
corporate governance
brand management

MMM’s Long-Term Risk Management Is The 91st Best In The Master List 82nd Percentile In The Master List)

Classification	S&P LT Risk-Management Global Percentile	Risk-Management Interpretation	Risk-Management Rating
BTI, ILMN, SIEGY, SPGI, WM, CI, CSCO, WMB, SAP, CL	100	Exceptional (Top 80 companies in the world)	Very Low Risk
3M	89	Very Good, Bordering on Exceptional	Very Low Risk
Strong ESG Stocks	86	Very Good	Very Low Risk
Foreign Dividend Stocks	77	Good, Bordering On Very Good	Low Risk
Ultra SWANs	74	Good	Low Risk
Dividend Aristocrats	67	Above-Average (Bordering On Good)	Low Risk
Low Volatility Stocks	65	Above-Average	Low Risk
Master List average	61	Above-Average	Low Risk
Dividend Kings	60	Above-Average	Low Risk
Hyper-Growth stocks	59	Average, Bordering On Above-Average	Medium Risk
Dividend Champions	55	Average	Medium Risk
Monthly Dividend Stocks	41	Average	Medium Risk

(Source: DK Research Terminal)

MMM’s risk-management consensus is in the top 18% of the world’s best blue-chips, and is similar to:

Royal Bank of Canada (RY): Ultra SWAN
Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS): Ultra SWAN
Medtronic (MDT): Ultra SWAN dividend aristocrat
Caterpillar (CAT): Ultra SWAN dividend aristocrat
Alphabet (GOOG): Ultra SWAN

The bottom line is that all companies have risks, and MMM is very good, bordering on exceptional, at managing theirs, according to S&P.

How We Monitor MMM’s Risk Profile

22 analysts
three credit rating agencies
25 experts who collectively know this business better than anyone other than management
the bond market for real-time fundamental risk-assessment

So 3M’s thesis isn’t broken, but that doesn’t mean it’s necessarily a great buy today.

What’s The Matter With 3M

6 months ago, 3M’s growth outlook was 8%, which is its historical growth rate for the past 20 years.

Combine a 5% yield and 8% growth, and you get a very attractive 13% long-term return potential.

Now?

Consensus Total Return Potential Ignoring Valuation

Investment Strategy	Yield	LT Consensus Growth	LT Consensus Total Return Potential	Long-Term Risk-Adjusted Expected Return	Long-Term Inflation And Risk-Adjusted Expected Returns	Years To Double Your Inflation & Risk-Adjusted Wealth	10-Year Inflation And Risk-Adjusted Expected Return
Nasdaq	0.8%	11.8%	12.6%	8.8%	6.5%	11.0	1.88
Safe Midstream	5.9%	6.4%	12.3%	8.6%	6.3%	11.5	1.84
Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF	3.5%	8.5%	12.0%	8.4%	6.0%	11.9	1.80
Dividend Aristocrats	2.6%	8.5%	11.1%	7.8%	5.4%	13.2	1.70
S&P 500	1.7%	8.5%	10.2%	7.1%	4.8%	15.0	1.60
REITs	3.9%	6.1%	10.0%	7.0%	4.7%	15.4	1.58
3M	4.7%	4.8%	9.5%	6.7%	4.3%	16.7	1.53

(Source: DK Research Terminal, FactSet, Ycharts, Morningstar)

3M’s total return potential has fallen so low that it’s expected to underperform most popular investing strategies.

Could 3M’s growth rate recover as Morningstar thinks it will? Of course, but if it doesn’t then 3M investors are left with a decent, if not exactly, life-changing investment opportunity.

Does that mean that 3M might not make an attractive medium-term buy purely due to valuation?

3M 2024 Consensus Total Return Potential

If 3M were to return to fair value and grow as expected through 2024, it could almost double, delivering Buffett-like 34% annual returns.

3M 2028 Consensus Total Return Potential

Over the next five years, 3M could deliver 139% total returns, or 15% annually.

14% to 17% CAGR five year consensus return potential range

That’s a very solid investment opportunity, assuming it grows as expected, which is no guarantee.

3M Investment Decision Score

Dividend Kings Automated Investment Decision Tool

MMM is a potentially excellent high-yield Ultra SWAN opportunity for anyone comfortable with its risk profile. Look at how it compares to the S&P 500.

38% discount to fair value vs. 3% premium S&P = 41% better valuation
4.7% very safe yield vs. 1.7% (3X higher and much safer)
approximately 9.5% long-term annual return potential vs. 10.2% CAGR S&P
about 50% higher risk-adjusted expected returns
2.5X higher income potential over five years

But while 3M is a potentially attractive high-yield aristocrat opportunity, it’s not my top recommendation by any means. Not when there are superior-yielding and faster-growing aristocrats available.

Enbridge: A 6.6% Yielding Aristocrat Firing On All Cylinders

Reasons To Potentially Buy Enbridge Today

Metric	Enbridge
Quality	85% 13/13 Ultra SWAN (Sleep Well at Night) Dividend Aristocrat
Risk Rating	Very Low Risk
DK Master List Quality Ranking (Out Of 500 Companies)	209
DK Master List Quality Percentile	59%
Dividend Growth Streak (Years)	28
Dividend Yield	6.7%
Dividend Safety Score	86%
Average Recession Dividend Cut Risk	0.5%
Severe Recession Dividend Cut Risk	1.70%
S&P Credit Rating	BBB+ Stable Outlook
30-Year Bankruptcy Risk	5.00%
LT S&P Risk-Management Global Percentile	96% Exceptional, Very Low Risk
Fair Value	$49.25
Current Price	$39.37
Discount To Fair Value	20%
DK Rating	Potential Strong Buy
P/Cash Flow	9.4
Growth Priced In	1.8%
Historical P/Cash Flow	9 to 12
LT Growth Consensus/Management Guidance	4.9%
5-year consensus total return potential	7% to 18% CAGR
Base Case 5-year consensus return potential	12% CAGR (2X S&P 500)
Consensus 12-month total return forecast	16%
Fundamentally Justified 12-Month Return Potential	28%
LT Consensus Total Return Potential	11.6%
Inflation-Adjusted Consensus LT Return Potential	9.3%
Consensus 10-Year Inflation-Adjusted Total Return Potential (Ignoring Valuation)	2.43
LT Risk-Adjusted Expected Return	7.71%
LT Risk-And Inflation-Adjusted Return Potential	5.38%
Conservative Years To Double	13.37

(Source: Dividend Kings Zen Research Terminal)

ENB’s long-term return potential (and guidance) is superior to MMM’s, and its five-year consensus return potential is basically identical.

2.1% per year higher returns over 30 years is potentially 87% more inflation-adjusted wealth

Enbridge 2024 Consensus Total Return Potential

ENB offers a very attractive 16% annual return potential over the next two years, 2X that of the S&P 500.

Enbridge 2028 Consensus Total Return Potential

ENB’s 11.5% annual return potential might not sound exciting, but it’s a potential double by 2028, 2X more than the S&P consensus.

And more importantly, ENB has a $120 trillion global green energy opportunity to tap into to keep growing steadily for decades to come.

the bond market thinks ENB is going to keep growing through 2112, at least
ENB will potentially outlive us all

ENB Investment Decision Score

ENB is a potentially good ultra-yield Ultra SWAN aristocrat opportunity for anyone comfortable with its risk profile. Look at how it compares to the S&P 500.

20% discount to fair value vs. 3% premium S&P = 23% better valuation
6.7% very safe yield vs. 1.7% (4X higher and much safer)
approximately 11.6% long-term annual return potential vs. 10.2% CAGR S&P
about 33% higher risk-adjusted expected returns
3.5X higher income potential over five years

Altria: An 8% Yielding Dividend King Growing Just As Fast As 3M

Further Reading:

Buy Altria Before August 26th, When Everyone Else Likely Will
deep dive look at MO’s investment thesis, growth outlook, and risk profile

Altria pretty much met expectations, as it has done consistently for a decade, outside of the Pandemic supply chain disruptions.

This is a very predictable business, which is what one would expect from a defensive dividend king with a 53-year dividend growth streak.

But that’s not to say there weren’t some worrisome things in MO’s report.

Altria reported weak cigarette volume and revenue in the third quarter of 2022. However, the positive mix meant that operating income of $3.1 billion and earnings per share of $1.28 were in line with our estimates…

Volume was weak, with cigarette volume down 9%, and down 10% when including trade inventory movements, and Altria lost almost 1 percentage point of retail share over the third quarter last year. The industry suffered an above-average volume decline rate (down 8%), and some trading down, as the impact of higher gas prices and broader inflationary pressures took their toll on smokers.” – Morningstar

MO’s volumes have been falling slightly faster than expected in recent quarters, though it’s been able to generate flat sales growth by raising prices.

Morningstar estimates it has about 30 more years in which it can do this before consumers revolt

Once again, Altria’s pricing power came to the fore, and cigarette net revenue was flat. The oral tobacco business continued its progress in the third quarter, with a 1% volume and almost 8% net revenue growth. On! again performed well, gaining 2 percentage points of retail share, and this masked volume weakness among the moist chewing tobacco brands.” – Morningstar

On!, its oral nicotine pouch brand, is currently the only reduced-risk product it sells after PM bought out its rights to iQos in the US.

MO is partnering with Japan Tobacco to commercialize heated tobacco and vaping in the US and remains the industry laggard behind PM and BTI.

Despite the volume pressure, operating income grew by 5.5%, and the EBIT margin was 57.5%, up by 415 basis points. We believe this improvement is largely due to the mix effect of the disposal of the wine business, which is maintainable to a degree, but we anticipate operating deleverage to gradually erode margins in the long term.” – Morningstar

MO’s strong cost discipline improved margins significantly, though Morningstar worried margins would eventually erode.

Analysts don’t share that concern. Here are MO’s consensus net margins.

2022: 41.3%
2023: 42.3%
2024: 43.3%
2025: 43.5%

And here are the consensus free cash flow margins:

2022: 34.5%
2023: 40.0%
2024: 40.3%
2025: 40.6%

MO remains one of the most profitable companies on earth, with free cash flow and net margins in the top 5% of global companies.

How worried about analysts about its ability to pivot to a smoke-free future?

MO almost always grows as expected and has been for 20 years. How does MO’s growth outlook compare to its major peers?

BTI: 10.4%
MO: 5.0%
PM: 3.1%

With growth matching 3M but a yield almost 2X as high, MO offers an exceptional long-term investment opportunity for anyone comfortable owning a tobacco company.

Reasons To Potentially Buy Altria Today

Metric	Altria
Quality	85% 13/13 Ultra SWAN (Sleep Well at Night) Dividend King
Risk Rating	Medium Risk
DK Master List Quality Ranking (Out Of 500 Companies)	216
DK Master List Quality Percentile	57%
Dividend Growth Streak (Years)	53
Dividend Yield	8.1%
Dividend Safety Score	86%
Average Recession Dividend Cut Risk	0.5%
Severe Recession Dividend Cut Risk	1.70%
S&P Credit Rating	BBB Stable Outlook
30-Year Bankruptcy Risk	7.50%
LT S&P Risk-Management Global Percentile	44% Average, Medium Risk
Fair Value	$70.10
Current Price	$46.20
Discount To Fair Value	34%
DK Rating	Potential Very Strong Buy
PE	9.5
Cash-Adjusted PE	8.6
Growth Priced In	0.2%
Historical PE	14 to 17
LT Growth Consensus/Management Guidance	5.0%
5-year consensus total return potential	16% to 20% CAGR
Base Case 5-year consensus return potential	19% CAGR (5X S&P 500)
Consensus 12-month total return forecast	14%
Fundamentally Justified 12-Month Return Potential	60%
LT Consensus Total Return Potential	13.1%
Inflation-Adjusted Consensus LT Return Potential	10.8%
Consensus 10-Year Inflation-Adjusted Total Return Potential (Ignoring Valuation)	2.78
LT Risk-Adjusted Expected Return	8.48%
LT Risk-And Inflation-Adjusted Return Potential	6.15%
Conservative Years To Double	11.70

(Source: Dividend Kings Zen Research Terminal)

MO is priced for 0.2% growth and is actually growing at 5%. It offers 3.6% better long-term return potential than MMM.

3X the inflation-adjusted wealth over 30 years compared to MMM

Altria 2024 Consensus Total Return Potential

Altria 2028 Consensus Total Return Potential

MO matches MMM for five-year return potential at about 15% to 16% per year but offers almost 2X the very safe yield and 3X the long-term wealth potential.

Altria Investment Decision Score

MO is a potentially good ultra-yield Ultra SWAN aristocrat opportunity for anyone comfortable with its risk profile. Look at how it compares to the S&P 500.

34% discount to fair value vs. 3% premium S&P = 37% better valuation
8.1% very safe yield vs. 1.7% (almost 5x higher and much safer)
approximately 13.1% long-term annual return potential vs. 10.2% CAGR S&P
about 66% higher risk-adjusted expected returns
4.5X higher income potential over five years

Bottom Line: 3M’s Thesis Has Weakened, So Consider High-Yield Aristocrat Alternatives

Don’t get me wrong, 3M is far from the next GE. Its dividend remains well covered by relatively stable free cash flow, its balance sheet is still A-rated, and legal liability fears are almost certainly significantly overblown.

That being said, with a growth outlook of just 4.8% and 9.5% long-term return potential, 3M is far from the best high-yield aristocrat you can buy.

Consensus Long-Term Return Potential (Ignoring Valuation)

Investment Strategy	Yield	LT Consensus Growth	LT Consensus Total Return Potential	Long-Term Risk-Adjusted Expected Return	Long-Term Inflation And Risk-Adjusted Expected Returns	Years To Double Your Inflation & Risk-Adjusted Wealth	10-Year Inflation And Risk-Adjusted Expected Return
Altria	8.1%	5.0%	13.1%	9.2%	6.8%	10.5	1.94
Nasdaq	0.8%	11.8%	12.6%	8.8%	6.5%	11.0	1.88
Safe Midstream	5.9%	6.4%	12.3%	8.6%	6.3%	11.5	1.84
Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF	3.5%	8.5%	12.0%	8.4%	6.0%	11.9	1.80
Enbridge	6.7%	4.9%	11.6%	8.1%	5.8%	12.4	1.76
Dividend Aristocrats	2.6%	8.5%	11.1%	7.8%	5.4%	13.2	1.70
S&P 500	1.7%	8.5%	10.2%	7.1%	4.8%	15.0	1.60
REITs	3.9%	6.1%	10.0%	7.0%	4.7%	15.4	1.58
3M	4.7%	4.8%	9.5%	6.7%	4.3%	16.7	1.53

(Sources: DK Research Terminal, FactSet, Morningstar, Ycharts)

With the 2023 recession likely to begin within four to five months, and legal uncertainties likely to drag on for years, 3M might not return to fair value until 2025.

Meanwhile, Altria and Enbridge represent higher-yielding, and faster-growing aristocrats, offering superior total return opportunities.

ENB offers almost 2X the inflation-adjusted returns of MMM over 30 years
MO offers 3X the inflation-adjusted returns of MMM over 30 years

Altria’s valuation is nearly as attractive as 3M’s; it’s less uncertain, and its 31% annual return potential through 2024 is almost as good.

Enbridge’s valuation might not be as attractive as MO or MMM’s, but it’s firing on all cylinders and has 96th-percentile risk management, according to S&P.

I have little double that anyone buying 3M today, or who bought it in 2022 and who holds for several years, will make money. The question is whether you’ll make a return as nice as what ENB and MO offer today.

Not even Buffett has unlimited funds to invest, and if you’re looking to buy a high-yield aristocrat today, I consider MO and ENB much more attractive long-term opportunities.